Blog · Expert evidence
Working time records as evidence: what an expert checks and what they can't decide
In an unpaid hours claim almost everything ends up revolving around one document: the working time record. If it's properly kept, it puts the dispute in order. If it has gaps, edits or suspiciously round numbers, that tells you something too. The expert is the one who reads it methodically and explains what it can support.
In a nutshell
Employers must record each worker's start and finish time every day and keep those records for four years (Art. 34.9 of the Spanish Workers' Statute).
In road transport the source is the tachograph: what you ask the company for are its downloads from the vehicle unit and the driver card.
The expert measures the hours and checks the integrity of the record. Whether hours count as overtime, whether availability is work or how much is owed is for the lawyer to argue and for the court to decide.
This article is accurate as of: 11/11/2026.
What the law requires to be recorded
- Daily working time record. The company must keep a daily record showing the exact start and finish time of each worker's day. It is set up by collective agreement, company agreement or, failing that, by the employer after consulting the workers' legal representatives. It is kept for four years and must be available to workers, their representatives and the Labour Inspectorate (Art. 34.9 of the Workers' Statute, ET).
- Overtime. For calculating overtime, working time is recorded day by day and totalled for each pay period, with a copy of the summary given to the worker with their payslip (Art. 35.5 ET).
- Mobile transport workers. The employer keeps a record of working time, retains it for at least three years after the period concerned and gives a copy of the record of hours worked to any worker who asks (Art. 10 bis.5 of Royal Decree 1561/1995).
What an expert checks in a time record
| What is checked | What the expert looks for |
|---|---|
| Origin and format | Whether it's on paper, an app, a clocking terminal or a spreadsheet. Whether what's been provided is the system's original export or a copy put together later. |
| Integrity | Who can edit the entries, whether the system logs changes and whether anything was changed after the date. |
| Internal consistency | Days with no entry, hours that are always round, identical days week after week or signatures added in bulk. |
| Cross-checking | Whether it matches other sources in the case file: payslips, the work calendar, holidays, emails or access logs. |
| Totals | Daily, weekly and annual totals, always with the source of each figure. |
A day with no record is a day with no data. The expert doesn't assume it was worked or rested: they note it's missing, list the possible causes (holiday, leave, sick leave, absence, on-call duty) and leave the matter to the lawyer.
In road transport, the record is the tachograph
In our professional view, with professional drivers there's no need to look for a separate time record to compare with the tachograph. The driver records driving, other work, availability and breaks or rest separately using the device's controls (Art. 34.5.b of Regulation (EU) 165/2014). That's why what you ask the company for are its downloads: those from the vehicle unit and those from the driver card.
From those files the report gives two separate figures: total working time (driving plus other work) and total time on duty, which also adds availability. Loading and unloading waits are measured one by one, because Royal Decree 1561/1995 treats the first two hours of each wait differently from the third hour onwards (Art. 10.4.c). We explain how that analysis works in what a tachograph expert witness does.
What the expert can't decide
- Whether hours are overtime in the legal sense or what they're worth in euros.
- Whether availability or presence time counts as work for the claim. The expert gives both figures and the court makes that call.
- Which collective agreement applies or how to read it. That's the lawyer's job.
- Whether the company has committed an offence. That's for the Labour Inspectorate and, where relevant, the courts.
- Which witness is telling the truth.
The court weighs expert reports according to the rules of sound judgement (Art. 348 of the Civil Procedure Act, LEC). In employment courts the expert presents and confirms the report at the hearing (Art. 93.1 of the Labour Jurisdiction Act, LRJS). A report that sticks to what it measures and says where every number comes from is the one that best withstands that scrutiny.
What's needed to commission one
- The original export of the working time record for the period, in the format the system produces.
- Payslips, the employment contract and the work calendar, with holidays and leave.
- The collective agreement the lawyer considers applicable, to identify the agreed working hours.
- In road transport, the driver card files (.ddd or .tgd) and the vehicle unit downloads.
It can be commissioned by the worker, their lawyer or the company. Mr Pedro Mulero Sánchez is an expert witness, member no. 03667 of the Aspejure association, with specific expert training in working time records and digital tachographs. To commission a report, get in touch through peritocamion.com.
Frequently asked questions
How long must the company keep the working time record?
Four years, under Art. 34.9 ET. For mobile transport workers, Royal Decree 1561/1995 requires the working time record to be kept for at least three years after the period concerned (Art. 10 bis.5).
Can the expert say whether I'm owed overtime?
No. They measure working time and compare it with the working hours they are given, with the source of each figure. Whether those hours are overtime and what they're worth is for the lawyer to argue and for the court to decide.
Is a spreadsheet record valid?
It's analysed like any other, but the expert will state how it was produced, who could change it and whether there's any trace of changes. That carries weight when the court assesses it.
What if days are missing from the record?
They're treated as days with no data. The report doesn't fill them in with guesses: it lists the possible causes and leaves it to the lawyer.
In road transport, do I also need a separate time record?
The source of a driver's working time is the tachograph. What you ask the company for are its downloads from the vehicle unit and the driver card.
Need a court-appointed expert?
Tell us about the case and the documents you have. We'll tell you whether there is a technical basis for an expert report and how it would be done.
Sources
- Royal Legislative Decree 2/2015, Workers' Statute, Arts. 34.9 and 35.5 (BOE, consolidated text updated 10/11/2026): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2015-11430#a34
- Royal Decree 1561/1995 on special working hours, Arts. 10.4 and 10 bis (BOE, updated 18/12/2025): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-1995-21346#a10bis
- Regulation (EU) 165/2014 on tachographs, Art. 34 (consolidated text as of 31/12/2024): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:02014R0165-20241231
- Spanish Civil Procedure Act (Law 1/2000), Art. 348 (BOE, updated 29/10/2026): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2000-323#a348
- Labour Jurisdiction Act (Law 36/2011), Art. 93 (BOE): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2011-15936#a93