Blog · Expert evidence
What a tachograph expert witness does and when you need one
When a driver claims unpaid hours or a haulier defends itself against a claim, the tachograph files usually say more than any witness. The tachograph expert witness is the person who reads them, puts them in order and explains to the judge what they say. And what they don't.
In a nutshell
A tachograph expert analyses the files from the driver card and the vehicle unit, with a digital fingerprint of each one so nobody can later argue they were tampered with.
From that data they measure driving, breaks, rest and working time day by day. Then they check the figures against the limits in Regulation (EC) 561/2006 and Spain's Royal Decree 1561/1995.
They measure hours but don't rule on them: whether availability counts as working time is for the court to decide. What to claim is for the lawyer.
This article is accurate as of: 11/11/2026.
What exactly they do
Spain's Civil Procedure Act (LEC) provides for expert evidence when technical knowledge is needed to assess relevant facts or establish them with certainty (Art. 335.1 LEC). A tachograph is exactly that: a device that records the driver's activity minute by minute in a format nobody can read at a glance.
The expert receives the files, checks they are intact, processes them and writes a report any judge can follow: what was measured, with what method, which file each figure comes from and what is left out. When issuing it, the expert promises to act as objectively as possible, taking into account both what may favour and what may harm each party (Art. 335.2 LEC). It doesn't matter who commissions it: the data is the same.
Which files they analyse
There are two main sources and it pays to have both.
| Source | What it stores | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Driver card | The holder's activities: driving, other work, availability and break or rest. Also the vehicles driven and manual entries. | It follows the driver from truck to truck. It is the basis for calculating their working time. |
| Vehicle unit | What happened in that truck: which cards were inserted and when, activities, driving without a card, events and faults. | It lets you cross-check the card and spot gaps, driving without a card or someone else's card. |
| Printouts and manual records | Printed tickets and the driver's own entries. | They fill in periods the device didn't record. |
Drivers must record each type of activity separately using the tachograph controls: driving, «other work», availability and break or rest (Art. 34.5.b of Regulation (EU) 165/2014). Those four categories are what the report is built around.
Before anything is opened, the SHA-256 fingerprint of each file is calculated. If someone later argues a file was altered, you just recalculate it: if it matches, it's the same file. When the European root public key is available, the digital signature the tachograph itself puts on the data is checked too.
What they can prove
- Driving: daily, weekly and fortnightly hours against the limits of nine hours a day (ten at most twice a week), 56 a week and 90 over two consecutive weeks (Art. 6 of Regulation (EC) 561/2006).
- Breaks: whether a break of at least 45 minutes, or one split into 15 and 30, followed four and a half hours of driving (Art. 7).
- Rest: daily and weekly, regular or reduced (Art. 8).
- Working time: total working time (driving plus other work) and total time on duty, which also adds availability.
- Loading and unloading waits: how long each one lasted. Where the conditions the provision sets out are met, Royal Decree 1561/1995 treats the first two hours of each wait as presence time and the third hour onwards as effective working time, unless its foreseeable length is known in advance under the terms agreed in the collective agreement (Art. 10.4.c).
- Night work, kilometres and vehicles driven in each period.
A day with no record is a day with no data. The report doesn't assume it was worked or rested: it says there is no record, lists the possible causes and leaves the matter to the lawyer.
What the expert doesn't decide
The expert measures hours. They don't give a legal classification of the facts. In particular:
- They don't decide whether availability or presence time counts as working time for the claim. They give both figures separately and the court makes that call.
- They don't say which collective agreement applies or how to read it. That's the lawyer's job.
- They don't turn hours into euros or say whether the company owes money.
- They don't assess witnesses or other evidence: the court weighs the expert report according to the rules of sound judgement (Art. 348 LEC).
That boundary doesn't weaken the report: it's what makes it hold up. An expert who strays into the legal side hands the other party the argument to discredit them.
When a lawyer or a driver asks for one
- A driver claiming unpaid hours or excess working time who wants to know what their own files say.
- An employment lawyer who needs months of records turned into orderly figures, each with its source, for the claim.
- A company facing a claim that wants to check the other side's numbers or answer an opposing expert report.
- A dismissal or a penalty where driving and rest times are the disputed fact.
- An accident where it matters how long the driver had been at the wheel and how much rest they'd had.
The sooner it's commissioned, the better. In civil proceedings a party's expert reports are filed with the claim or the defence (Art. 336.1 LEC). In employment courts expert evidence is given at the hearing, where the expert presents and confirms the report (Art. 93.1 of the Labour Jurisdiction Act, LRJS). Either way, the lawyer needs the finished report before that date.
How Mr Pedro Mulero works
Mr Pedro Mulero Sánchez is an expert witness, member no. 03667 of the Aspejure association, with specific expert training in digital tachographs and driving times. Before turning to expert work he was a professional driver and a fleet maintenance manager: he has used the tachograph every day from the cab.
The work is document-based and the truck doesn't need to go anywhere. He receives the card files and, where available, the vehicle unit files. They are processed on an offline computer, logged in the case register with their fingerprint and the report is written. We explain how that tool works in how we produce expert reports without the data leaving the computer.
To commission a report or ask whether your case needs one, get in touch through peritocamion.com.
Frequently asked questions
What does the expert need to get started?
The driver card files (.ddd or .tgd) for the disputed period and, if possible, the vehicle unit downloads. Printed tickets or manual entries too, if there are any. That's what the document review is based on.
Can the driver ask the company for their records?
Royal Decree 1561/1995 requires the employer to keep a record of mobile workers' working time, to keep it for at least three years and to give a copy of the record of hours worked to any worker who asks (Art. 10 bis.5).
Does the report say whether I'm owed overtime?
No. It measures total working time and total time on duty, each figure with its source. What to claim and what it's worth is for your lawyer to argue and for the court to decide.
What if the company files its own report?
The court weighs both according to the rules of sound judgement (Art. 348 LEC). What counts there is that every figure can be traced back to the exact file and record it comes from.
Does the truck have to be taken anywhere?
No. The analysis is done on the downloaded files and the truck can keep working.
Need a court-appointed expert?
Tell us about the case and the documents you have. We'll tell you whether there is a technical basis for an expert report and how it would be done.
Sources
- Spanish Civil Procedure Act (Law 1/2000), Arts. 335, 336 and 348 (BOE, consolidated text updated 29/10/2026): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2000-323#a335
- Labour Jurisdiction Act (Law 36/2011), Art. 93 (BOE): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2011-15936#a93
- Regulation (EU) 165/2014 on tachographs, Art. 34 (consolidated text as of 31/12/2024): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:02014R0165-20241231
- Regulation (EC) 561/2006, Arts. 6, 7 and 8 (consolidated text as of 31/12/2024): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:02006R0561-20241231
- Royal Decree 1561/1995 on special working hours, Arts. 10 and 10 bis (BOE, updated 18/12/2025): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-1995-21346#a10