Blog · Expert evidence
Hidden defects in a vehicle: when you need an expert report and how it works
You buy a car, a few months later something serious goes wrong and the seller says it's wear and tear or that it's your fault. From that point the argument stops being mechanical and becomes about evidence: what's wrong, since when and whether it could be seen when you bought it.
In a nutshell
A hidden defect is a fault that already existed at the time of sale, couldn't be seen and makes the vehicle unfit for use or impairs it so much that you wouldn't have bought it or would have paid less (Art. 1484 of the Spanish Civil Code).
An expert report is needed when the origin or age of the defect is disputed or when a price reduction has to be quantified, which the Civil Code leaves «to the judgement of experts».
The work is document-based: the garage diagnoses, dismantles and photographs. The expert reviews those documents and photos and writes the report. The lawyer handles the legal side.
This article is accurate as of: 11/11/2026.
What a hidden defect is and which rules apply
The Spanish Civil Code makes the seller liable for hidden defects in the item sold if they make it unfit for its intended use or reduce that use so much that, had the buyer known, they wouldn't have bought it or would have paid less (Art. 1484 CC). The seller isn't liable for obvious defects or those in plain sight.
If you bought as a consumer from a business, such as a dealership or a used car trader, the lack of conformity rules in the consolidated Spanish Consumer Protection Act also apply to the sale of goods (Art. 114 TRLGDCU). In Catalonia, sales also have their own rules in Book Six of the Catalan Civil Code (Law 3/2017).
| Regime | When it applies | Time limits it sets |
|---|---|---|
| Civil Code | Sales in general, including between private individuals. | Actions expire six months after delivery (Art. 1490 CC). |
| TRLGDCU | A consumer buying from a business. | The seller is liable for lack of conformity that existed on delivery and becomes apparent within three years. For second-hand goods a shorter period can be agreed, never less than one year (Art. 120). Unless proven otherwise, faults appearing in the first two years are presumed to have existed on delivery. For second-hand goods that presumption period can also be agreed shorter, but not below the liability period (Art. 121). |
Which regime applies to your case and how the time limits are counted is for your lawyer to decide. The expert doesn't go there.
When an expert report is needed
When technical knowledge is needed to assess a fact or establish it with certainty, the law provides for expert evidence (Art. 335.1 of the Civil Procedure Act, LEC). With a hidden defect, that usually happens in these situations:
- The seller says the fault is normal wear or misuse while you argue the defect was already there when you bought the car.
- The presumption that the defect existed on delivery no longer applies and its origin has to be proven.
- It has to be explained whether the defect could be seen or detected at purchase, because the seller isn't liable for obvious defects.
- A price reduction is sought: the Civil Code leaves it «to the judgement of experts» (Art. 1486 CC).
- A claim is about to be filed: a party's expert reports go in with the claim (Art. 336.1 LEC).
What the expert reviews
A hidden defect report is built from paperwork and photos. The usual material is:
- The purchase contract or invoice and the sale advert.
- The service history and roadworthiness inspections.
- The garage's diagnostic reports, with fault codes and readings.
- Repair orders, quotes and invoices.
- Correspondence between the garage and the manufacturer, plus any recalls or technical bulletins affecting the model.
- Photographs of the dismantled parts.
With that the expert answers the technical questions: what caused the fault, whether it fits the mileage and use, how long it may have been there and whether it could be spotted with the naked eye at the time of purchase.
How it works, step by step
- Document review of the case. We go through what you already have: purchase, advert, invoices and reports. That shows what's missing and which technical questions need answering.
- The garage's documents. You ask for them in writing, because as the owner you're entitled to them and it's harder for the garage to refuse you. If they make difficulties, you sign an authorisation and the expert requests them on your behalf, strictly for technical information.
- Photos of the parts. The garage keeps the replaced parts without cleaning them and photographs each one from several angles, in the original file. The expert reviews those photos. The parts are kept as evidence.
- Feasibility study. It measures how technically and evidentially solid the case is. It isn't a forecast of what the judge will say.
- Out-of-court claim. It is signed and sent by the owner or their lawyer. The expert doesn't make claims on anyone's behalf: if they did, the other side could question their impartiality.
- Expert report. It's written using all the documents in the case file.
- Legal assistance. With the report and the documents, the lawyer works out the strategy and files the claim. The expert explains the technical side in court.
Who does what
| Who | What they do |
|---|---|
| The garage | Inspects the vehicle, diagnoses, dismantles, keeps the parts and photographs them. |
| You | Provide your documents, ask the garage for theirs and sign the claim. |
| The expert | Reviews the documents and photos, writes the report and explains it in court. |
| The lawyer | Decides the strategy, keeps track of time limits and files the claim. |
Mr Pedro Mulero Sánchez doesn't inspect vehicles or examine parts: that's the garage's job. He works with the information provided by the client or the garage and writes the report from that documentation.
The Civil Procedure Act requires an expert to hold the official qualification for the subject matter (Art. 340.1 LEC). His is a Spanish second-level vocational qualification (FP II) in Automotive, specialising in Vehicle Mechanics and Electrics. He is an expert witness, member no. 03667 of the Aspejure association, with specific expert training in hidden vehicle defects.
What to do before the repair
- Ask the garage for the diagnostic report with the fault codes.
- Have them photograph the vehicle and each part before and during dismantling.
- Have them keep the replaced parts without cleaning or throwing them away.
- Save a copy of the sale advert: the seller can edit or delete it.
- Make your requests by email so there's a record.
To commission a review of your case, get in touch through peritocamion.com.
Frequently asked questions
Does the expert come to see the car?
No. Mr Pedro Mulero doesn't inspect vehicles: the garage does that. He reviews the documents and photos provided by the client or the garage. He only travels if the client expressly asks for it, with a separate quote accepted.
Do I have to send the parts?
No. The garage keeps the parts, uncleaned, as evidence. What gets sent are photos of each part from several angles, in the original file and uncropped.
How long do I have to make a claim?
It depends on the regime. The Civil Code gives six months from delivery (Art. 1490 CC) while consumer law makes a business seller liable for faults appearing within three years (Art. 120 TRLGDCU). Your lawyer will tell you which applies to your case and how it's counted.
Does the report come before or after the claim?
The document review and the out-of-court claim come first. If the seller doesn't respond or there's no agreement, the report is the technical evidence the lawyer files with the claim.
What if the car has already been repaired?
We work with whatever there is: invoices, diagnostic report, photos and the parts if the garage kept them. The more documentation there is, the easier it is to establish where the defect came from.
Need a court-appointed expert?
Tell us about the case and the documents you have. We'll tell you whether there is a technical basis for an expert report and how it would be done.
Sources
- Spanish Civil Code, Arts. 1484, 1486 and 1490 (BOE, consolidated text updated 07/09/2026): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-1889-4763#art1484
- Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, consolidated Consumer Protection Act, Arts. 114, 120 and 121 (BOE, updated 04/11/2026): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2007-20555#a120
- Spanish Civil Procedure Act (Law 1/2000), Arts. 335, 336 and 340 (BOE, updated 29/10/2026): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2000-323#a335
- Law 3/2017, Book Six of the Catalan Civil Code on obligations and contracts (BOE): https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2017-2466